Give Constructive Feedback

Ineffective feedback: Are You Unable To Give Constructive Feedback?

It’s undeniable that good communication is the key to a healthy team. Feedback is essential to improving the team’s performance. Its vital role cannot be understated. However, things can go south if a manager shares ineffective feedback. Sometimes, the manager may not understand the crucial role feedback plays and neglect it. But what happens when the manager gives ineffective feedback? The team can quickly start to feel frustrated, lost, and demoralized. This blog aims to explain the importance of constructive feedback, what happens when managers give ineffective feedback, and how to provide it effectively. Doing so will ensure that your team feels confident and supported, leading to a stronger and more productive work environment.

What is Constructive Feedback?

As we understand, feedback simply refers to the supervisor’s comments on the job done by the employees. It can include their views, an appraisal, or other information regarding the task. Constructive feedback takes it one step ahead. Constructive feedback is crafted to aid improvement in the team. It should be specific, action-oriented, and timely. It will help the individual receiving feedback to understand what they need to work on more closely and how they can improve their skills. Along with comments, the managers also highlight areas that need extra effort and suggest solutions for better performance. The final goal is to help and guide the individual towards a better performance.

Constructive feedback is not harmful simply because it aims at improvement. On the contrary – constructive criticism allows people to learn from their mistakes while still maintaining some sense of pride in their accomplishments. An external perspective gives them a bird’s eye view of their actions. When people see their actions together, they can look for loopholes and possible opportunities for improvement.

What is ineffective feedback? With examples

Ineffective feedback from managers can have a negative impact on employee morale and performance. Some common examples of ineffective feedback from managers include being too critical without offering specific solutions or constructive feedback, failing to provide feedback altogether, giving feedback too late, or ignoring individual strengths and focusing solely on weaknesses.

Additionally, managers who provide feedback that is inconsistent or contradictory can cause confusion and frustration for employees. When feedback is not given with a genuine desire to help employees improve, it can be perceived as manipulative or insincere, further eroding trust and morale. Ultimately, ineffective feedback from managers can undermine the relationship between managers and employees, and lead to a decline in performance and productivity.

Ineffective feedback looks like:

  • Overwhelming feedback: Giving too much feedback at once can be overwhelming and difficult to process. It is better to provide specific feedback on a few key areas at a time, rather than overwhelming the recipient with too much information.
  • Feedback that lacks context: Feedback that is not contextualized can be confusing and unhelpful. It is important to provide specific examples and context to help the recipient understand the feedback and apply it in the future.
  • Insincere feedback: Feedback that is insincere or not genuine can be demotivating and unproductive. It is important to provide honest feedback that is intended to help the recipient improve, rather than just going through the motions of providing feedback.

Are you giving ineffective feedback?

While managers try to provide constructive feedback, which helps their teams grow, ineffective feedback can slowly creep into the process. If you lack points and wonder where to help the team members before stepping into a feedback meeting, it might signal you need to get started on a review yourself. The best way to review your feedback skills is direct – ask the people who receive feedback from you directly. But, it comes with its problems; hesitation, bias, or even faulty judgment. A free assessment on Constructive Feedback skills can save your day. Get started now to get detailed insights.

P.S. Risely helps managers solve team challenges like a buddy! Along with constructive feedback skills, Risely provides customized solutions to managers in over 30+ areas that team managers get stuck with. You can start your learning journey today with a free 14-day trial to your true potential.

Why Is It Important For Managers To Give Constructive Feedback?

Giving constructive feedback is one of the most important tasks that a manager can undertake. It’s important for two primary reasons: it ensures that employees perform to the best of their ability and helps maintain positive relationships with employees. If done correctly, constructive feedback can positively impact team performance and overall morale. It’s an essential part of the manager’s job, and they must be able to give feedback in the right way for the best outcome.

Giving constructive feedback can be difficult, but it is an important part of team building. Feedback must be given to the receiver will understand and appreciate it. Too often, feedback is given in a way that the recipient feels attacked or misunderstood. Additionally, feedback that is not actionable or timely can be ineffective and even harmful. When providing feedback, it is important to be specific, actionable, and timely. Doing so will help the receiver understand the task and take the necessary steps to improve. Ultimately, providing constructive feedback is essential for healthy team culture.

What Happens When A Manager Gives Ineffective Feedback?

As we have noted, constructive feedback is immensely helpful in guiding people in their journeys. Instead of figuring out everything independently, they can directly begin working as someone has identified areas that need attention. The lack of constructive feedback slowly but surely impacts the team in many ways. The team suffers due to:

Improvement Becomes Difficult

Feedback, when done smartly, helps employees lay out an improvement plan. It is crucial in the development of a growth journey for individuals. Ineffective feedback makes it difficult to know where you stand. Consequently, employees will not be able to understand whether they need improvement or not. The burden on self-assessment becomes too high. Additionally, the advantage of an outsider’s experienced view is lost. Effectively, the employee is left to their means to see where they can go.

Moreover, the question of how to improve goes unresolved. A manager or a leader who provides feedback can also suggest solutions that they might be aware of, owing to experience and expertise. Without this, the employee has to look for avenues themselves. Due to a lack of knowledge, they will have a hard time evaluating the alternatives present in front of them. All in all, employees’ learning journey faces a major roadblock when feedback is replaced with silence. Individuals may feel lost or unsure about what steps they need to take for the team to function at its best.

Employee Morale And Engagement Falls

Feedback is a great way for managers and leaders to establish regular communication with their teams. Managers can build great relationships with their employees through performance reviews and one-on-one meetings. These connections make them feel valued and serve as motivational tools. In the absence of constructive feedback, employees start to feel lost. They do not understand their role in the organization and their expectations. This leads to a sense of unease or confusion among team members.

Lack of engagement can also be seen as a morale issue since it significantly impacts productivity. In fact, research has shown employees who are engaged with their teams regularly receive feedback, as opposed to those who are not. As a result, organizations should ensure that all employees receive regular feedback to grow and learn. Feedback boosts employee morale and leads to better performance as it promotes personal growth.

Employee Dissatisfaction Rises

Employees start to feel discontent when feedback is missing. This stems from the fact that they do not understand what their counterparts are doing or how they can improve. As a result, many employees turn to other avenues to figure out what they need to do for the team to function at its best. Often, this leads them down a path of dissatisfaction as they look for someone else who can provide them with constructive feedback.

Sometimes, these individuals leave their jobs due to a lack engagement and satisfaction. This can also happen as they cannot envisage any professional development for themselves in the situation. Furthermore, when an employee does leave their job, it can cause a ripple effect in the team since other members start to feel disgruntled. This ultimately leads to turnover rates being much higher than expected.

Growth Stagnates

When ineffective feedback is given, employees do not grow as they should. This results in them stagnating at their current level and becoming less capable of meeting the demands posed by their work. Furthermore, when people are provided with constructive feedback but don’t feel like it is helping them achieve their goals, they may become complacent. This means they stop trying hard because they think things will automatically improve on their own accord.

As a result, team productivity levels can take a significant hit, and progress may even come to a standstill. The team begins working at a lower level as members fail to grow due to a lack of feedback and constructive criticism. This can lead to a less productive environment and, ultimately, decreased profits. Effectively, growth stagnates at one point as people begin to become complacent in the absence of expressed oversight.

Withholding feedback or giving it destructively hurts the recipient and the team as a whole. It’s important to be clear and concise with feedback so that the recipient can understand and implement it effectively. This way, everyone can work towards the common goal – creating a successful team!

Common Reasons Managers Do Not Give Constructive Feedback

When it comes to giving constructive feedback, many people often struggle for a few reasons.

  • Managers do not know how to give feedback: First of all, it’s hard to know when or how to give feedback, and when you finally do, employees may not appreciate it. Crafting constructive feedback requires time, effort, and sincerity on behalf of the person giving the feedback. A new manager, in particular, may not know how to give feedback.
  • Feedback takes time: Moreover, giving individual feedback is a huge task, especially in bigger teams. The managers may find it difficult to give attention to each employee when they are spread too thin.
  • Manager might feel uncomfortable: Further, people often feel shy or uncomfortable when giving feedback, especially if they don’t know the person they’re giving feedback to. They may also be afraid of making their team member feel uncomfortable or criticized. The fear of demotivating employees can make managers hold back too.
  • Personal relations may get involved: Apart from these common struggles, other factors sometimes influence how people give feedback. For example, a person’s status in the company or relationship with the team member might impact how they give feedback. If a manager fears that a relationship will be jeopardized, they might hesitate before giving feedback to employees.
  • Fear of negative reaction: Managers might hold back from giving feedback due to the expected reaction too. For feedback to work, the employee needs to see it as support rather than criticism. The manager will be discouraged if the employee reacts defensively to receiving feedback.

How To Avoid Giving Ineffective Feedback?

If you’re struggling to give constructive feedback, it’s likely because you’re uncomfortable with it. But don’t worry, there are a few ways to get over your fear and give feedback that is both effective and helpful.


The lack of constructive feedback can hurt team morale and productivity. Managers must be aware of the importance of feedback and ensure that it is given in a constructive and meaningful way. By following these tips, you can help your team to grow and develop in the right way. So what are you waiting for? Start giving constructive feedback today!

Overcome limitations with the free constructive feedback toolkit.

Download the free constructive feedback toolkit today to solve all your feedback troubles.


What are some examples of ineffective feedback?

Some examples of ineffective feedback:
Vague feedback: Feedback that is too general or vague can be confusing and unhelpful. For example, saying “good job” without specifying what was done well does not give the recipient any useful information.
Personal attacks: Feedback that attacks the recipient personally instead of focusing on specific behaviors or actions is unproductive and can be hurtful. For example, saying “you’re lazy” instead of “you need to work on meeting your deadlines” is not helpful.
Bias-based feedback: Feedback that is influenced by bias, such as stereotypes or prejudice, is not effective. For example, saying “women are not good at math” is a biased statement that does not provide helpful feedback.

What is ineffective feedback in the workplace?

Ineffective feedback in the workplace refers to feedback which does not help team members improve. It is provided for the sake of fulfilling requirements rather than guiding the improvement of team members. Ineffective feedback in the workplace hampers growth and limits the potential of growing relationships too.

What is the difference between effective and ineffective feedback?

Effective feedback facilitates growth and allows team members to communicate with their managers on issues relating to their performance and productivity. Ineffective feedback, on the other hand, does not lead them toward the path of learning and development. Instead, it confuses and demotivates employees.

Other Related Blogs

how to receive feedback with a growth mindset

How To Receive Feedback With A Growth Mindset?

How To Receive Feedback With A Growth Mindset? Receiving feedback is an essential part of personal and professional growth. But let’s be honest. We frequently struggle to accept feedback and…

How to give constructive feedback to employees?

How to give constructive feedback to employees? Have you ever sought directions while driving? What’s better?  Go straight and take the second left.  It’s ahead somewhere toward the left. If…

From Engineer to Entrepreneur: The Story of Ashish Manchanda

From Engineer to Entrepreneur: The Story of Ashish Manchanda In a world saturated with stories of engineers turned entrepreneurs, we often skim the surface of their journeys, passing judgment on…

Your Team Needs Actionable Feedback: 5 Ways to do it right

Your Team Needs Actionable Feedback: 5 Ways to do it right As a manager, giving feedback to your team is an essential part of your role. But what sets actionable…

Comments are closed.