leadership mentors

Pros and Cons of Using Leadership Mentors for Skill Building

As a manager, you know that leadership and managerial skills are essential for success. But developing these skills can be challenging. Having a good leadership mentor can help in this journey. A mentor is someone who can provide guidance and support as you work to develop your leadership and managerial skills. There are many benefits to using a leadership mentor, including improved communication, teamwork skills, and problem-solving abilities. However, there are also some potential downsides to consider, such as the time and money required for mentorship. To make the best decision for you, ask yourself some questions about using a leadership mentor – and then get started!

Who is a Leadership Mentor?

Skills development is essential for any leader – whether you’re a beginner or an experienced professional. But sometimes, finding the right resources or tools to help you achieve your goals can be challenging. That’s where a leadership mentor comes in. A mentor is a person who has the experience and knowledge to offer guidance and support. They have been in your shoes and done with the problems you might be currently facing.

They can act as a sounding board for your ideas and help you develop your skills in leadership. They should also have the requisite skills to give constructive feedback – someone with expertise in the area you’re trying to improve. Having a mentor can significantly assist your skills development and help you achieve your goals faster.

Leadership mentoring programs are typically conducted to train employees for leadership roles. Using this method, the employees can gain leadership insights from people who have already been in the role. This makes things easier as you do not have to figure out everything from scratch.

Pros of Using Leadership Mentors

There’s no doubt that leadership is an important skill and one that can be improved through dedicated training and mentorship. However, there are a few pros to using leadership mentors for skill building.

Gain experience-based know-how and insights

Firstly, a leadership mentor can give you insights into different management styles and how they’ve been successful in the past. This can give you a better understanding of the management techniques that are currently in use and help you develop a better work ethic. The mentee understands management techniques and organizational functioning, which will be beneficial when taking up new roles or responsibilities within the company. In addition, it can lead to a more cohesive and united team, resulting in improved performance. The mentor’s experience can give the mentees many invaluable nuggets of wisdom.

Get guidance for the future

Secondly, a leadership mentor can guide you on the latest trends in management. This can come in handy when making decisions about your career or choosing which challenges to take on next. By having access to advice from an experienced individual, you’ll be able to make well-informed choices that will help you progress within your field. By choosing the right mentor, you’ll gain access to expert advice and develop critical skills that will stand you in good stead regardless of your next path.

Secondly, a leadership mentor can also help you plan your future career moves and guide you on the best way to achieve them. This is especially helpful if you are unsure where you want to head in your career or how best to get there. Additionally, it can be helpful to have someone to discuss challenges you’re experiencing in your career path. Using a leadership mentor can be a great way to boost your confidence and skill set and increase your chances of success in your career.

Empathy with a human element

Thirdly, a leadership mentor can be instrumental in building empathy and understanding for your team members. This is because they’ll likely have had similar experiences in their careers, which makes them more able to relate to your situation as well as the challenges that you’re facing.

In addition, a good leadership mentor will also be mindful of the human element – meaning they’ll consider things like emotions and relationships when providing mentorship advice. Doing this creates an environment where everyone feels respected and valued – essential ingredients for effective leadership.

Learn to ask questions

Fourthly, a good leadership mentor will know how to give and take feedback effectively. This is because they’ll have learned the art of asking questions to understand what needs to change. They’re also comfortable giving constructive criticism, which can be difficult for some people. By learning these skills early on in your career, you can build a strong foundation for future success as a leader. Through these interactions, managers can learn to ask great questions that give helpful insights.

Career development and networking

Fifthly, a leadership mentor can also be instrumental in helping you develop your career and achieve greater heights. This is because they’ll help you identify where you want to go and how to get there. Additionally, they’ll often have connections that can lead to opportunities you wouldn’t otherwise find. These networking opportunities are often hard to find. As a result, working with a good leadership mentor can benefit you professionally and personally.

A leadership mentor can also enhance the mentee’s networking skills and capabilities. They are likely to know people who could offer valuable expertise or support when taking on new challenges through their contacts. This can help you to build a strong network of contacts that can be highly beneficial when it comes to finding new jobs or advancing your career.

Cons of Using Leadership Mentors

Anyone can benefit from the guidance and skills of a leadership mentor. However, before you take the plunge and hire one, consider the pros and cons. The cost of using a leadership mentor may be worth it if you feel that having advice from an expert will help improve your career growth rate.

Compatibility issues

One of the potential downsides of using a leadership mentor is that they may not be compatible with your attitude or work style. If you like to take charge, a leadership mentor may not be your best choice. They might try to push and prod you in directions that don’t necessarily reflect your interests or strengths.

Sometimes, this can damage relationships with colleagues or customers because it won’t conform to their view of how things should be done. You also risk becoming overwhelmed by their advice if it goes against what feels natural for you as an individual. Moreover, a mismatch in central values can give way to lots of misunderstandings and clashes.

May not have expertise or ability to mentor

Before you commit to using a leadership mentor, be sure to investigate their qualifications and experience. Often, they may not have the expertise or ability to offer meaningful guidance. This could lead to wasted time and energy if you’re looking for someone who can help you grow as an individual leader.

Also, a mentor may be competent in their role, but it would be difficult for one person to offer you the whole breadth of any subject. Their knowledge can go in-depth only so much. At some point or the other, they might run out of solutions for you because they are also a human being in a similar position, albeit with a more fantastic experience.

Finally, even if a leadership mentor does have the skills and expertise to help you grow as a leader, it’s possible that they simply don’t have the personal qualities or temperament to be successful in this role. They may be unable to relate well to people or build strong relationships. This could make it hard for them to provide sound advice and support when needed.

Hesitation in asking for a favor

If you’re hesitant to ask for help from a leadership mentor, this could be another downside. You may think it’s too much of a commitment, or you don’t need their help. This can lead to paralysis in the face of an obstacle or challenge, ultimately hindering your leadership progress.

Moreover, you might get leadership mentoring from someone as a favor. In the future, you may have to return that favor and not want to get into a tricky transactional relationship.

Hard to find a good mentor

One of the main challenges when seeking a leadership mentor is finding someone qualified and willing to help can be difficult. This can make finding a suitable match challenging, especially if you’re looking for someone with expertise in specific areas. Moreover, people who are good at mentoring often don’t always want the added responsibility or public acclaim that comes with this role.

This could be another negative factor if your leadership mentor is not always available. For example, they might be traveling for work or out sick, so they won’t have time to offer guidance and support on specific topics. This can leave you feeling lost and unsupported, slowing down your growth as a leader.

Moreover, if your vision for success does not align with your mentor’s, you will encounter confusion and strife. While choosing a mentor, it is crucial to pick someone whose beliefs do not set limits for your potential.

Dependence and loyalty issues

This could be a significant issue if a leadership mentor is too dependent on you or loyal only to themselves. They may not be willing to give criticism. Constructively, and they might not offer sound advice when it’s needed most. This can lead to burnout and frustration on your part, as well as decreased motivation levels.

Mentor-mentee relationships can create dependency as well. Wherein the person cannot make decisions independent of the mentor’s input. The other employees can also raise questions about your loyalty after observing your close relationship with one person. Employees can become committed to their mentor and professional development while losing touch with the organization.

Questions to Ask a Leadership Mentor

There are countless benefits to using leadership mentors for skill building. They offer guidance and mentorship, help students develop new skills, and boost their confidence. Beginning a mentorship session with a handy list of questions prepared beforehand would be best. Before beginning the session, you should be clear about your objectives and how you will engage. The aim is to gain the best insights from the conversation. Here are a few examples of questions that you can ask your mentor.

  • What is the source of your motivation?
  • Are there any books that you would suggest every potential leader read?
  • How do you establish a work-life balance?
  • How do you approach challenges and unconventional situations? What are the common challenges in this role?
  • Which skills have potential in the industry right now? How should I choose things to learn?

Overcoming limitations of mentorship

As we have noted, there are several limitations in using a leadership mentor, despite the benefits it offers. These limitations can sometimes become a significant factor that can keep one from focusing on developing managerial skills. To overcome these, we first need to envisage the ideal medium for coaching leaders and managers. A few basic features of this medium would include:

Easy to approach

The ideal alternative should be easy to approach. Although the human factor in mentorship is a great addition, it can be the primary inhibitor for many people. They might feel ashamed to seek help. Their actions can become a subject of gossip and judgment within the organization, and consequently, people will shy away from looking for mentorship. To overcome this, the medium needs to be easy to approach along with interactive. A balance of both elements is essential to keeping the audience engaged.

Non-transactional relationships

The transactional nature of the mentorship relationship becomes apparent as it is somewhere between personal and professional. The exchange of favors can put many people in uncomfortable positions. Therefore, we understand that a training method must avoid interpersonal relationships. In short, the medium should avoid creating dependency and loyalty issues with the individual. Objectivity and impartiality are needed as critical features.

Values and beliefs match

Leadership training is about getting the values and beliefs that the existing leaders hold. Moreover, the personal values of the individual are also important. A mismatch between the learner and the teacher will leave them in internal conflict. Otherwise, it can lead to confusion in terms of direction and objectives. The ideal alternative would ensure that there is no mismatch, along with a commitment from both parties to grow together through learning new things. The alignment of key values will help them develop a vision for which they can work together.

High availability and scalability

The ideal alternative should also be scalable. This means that it can accommodate a wide range of people and their needs which, in turn, leads to high availability. The level of expertise required for effective mentorship is not available everywhere. However, this does not mean that there are no good resources out there. Most experts do not offer their services as mentorships due to the earlier scalability factor.

Hence, a platform that brings together insights from numerous sources would be ideal. This would help them develop a better understanding of different concepts as well as how they can be applied in practice. Furthermore, access to such resources will allow learners to widen their perspectives on management issues and develop innovative solutions.

In-depth and broad expertise needed

Lastly, a much-needed feature of any place offering training to leaders and managers is abroad scope of knowledge. A single person will not be able to provide a broad enough perspective. In order to create an array of well-equipped leaders, several resources and methods would be required. Instead of a monotonous approach, it would be best to combine a few methods. This can include long-form written content like blogs, engaging videos, interactive nudges that motivate, courses for in-depth immersion into concepts, and toolkits for practical guidance.

The abovementioned elements provide a better understanding of how one can choose things to learn when one aspires to become a better leader or manager. Although experience is the best teacher, it is not always possible to have access to all the necessary knowledge. In such cases, using technology can be a great way of overcoming this limitation. Platforms like Risley, the only AI-based coaching tool, can help managers and leaders achieve personal development goals. It offers a great deal of knowledge – served in an enviably simple and effective manner.


Many businesses struggle to find the right balance between work and personal life. This often results in employees who are burnt out and unfocused. To combat this issue, many businesses turn to leadership mentors to help them build the skills necessary for success in their careers. While there are many benefits to using a leadership mentor, you must weigh them carefully before deciding. Additionally, ask yourself some key questions about whether or not a leadership mentor is right for you. We hope this blog was helpful and that you will consider the points before using a leadership mentor in the future!

Keep growing the free growth mindset toolkit for managers.

Download the free growth mindset toolkit for managers to unlock insights and frameworks to cultivate a winning attitude in your team.

Other Related Blogs

Interviewer Skills

5 Interviewer Skills That Every Manager Needs For Smart Hiring

5 Interviewer Skills That Every Manager Needs For Smart Hiring Interviewing is one of the most essential skills that you need to have if you want to pursue a career…

Why Do Managers Need Skill Development And Training? 6 Top Ways

Why Do Managers Need Skill Development And Training? 6 Top Ways Managers in the office have a lot of responsibilities, and it can be challenging to keep up with everything.…

The Art of Assertiveness: How To Master It As A Manager?

The Art of Assertiveness: How To Master It As A Manager? Assertiveness is the ability to communicate effectively and assertively with others. It’s one of the most critical skills a…

Comments are closed.